There is a idea typically invoked in tabletop RPGs: the “Rule of Cool”. It means, it is alright to bend the foundations of the sport you are taking part in, so long as it is within the title of constructing one thing thrilling and enjoyable occur. Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Amongst Thieves virtually makes it its mission assertion.
When this large price range movie adaptation of the enduring tabletop recreation was first revealed, some pedantic hay was manufactured from the truth that the druid character makes use of her Wild Form potential within the trailer to show into an owlbear—one thing technically inconceivable underneath the foundations of the sport. Individuals prone to degree that form of criticism will most likely have a mind aneurysm once they witness her rework right into a dozen totally different animals over the course of a beautiful one-shot escape sequence.
(opens in new tab)
However you’ll be able to’t bend the foundations should you do not acknowledge them within the first place—and regardless of any liberties it takes within the title of cinematic motion, Honor Amongst Thieves feels remarkably trustworthy to the tabletop recreation. It does not damage that it is also only a actually enjoyable fantasy film.
My misgivings about D&D’s place within the fashionable RPG business are well-recorded, and there is definitely a contact of the company round Honor Amongst Thieves. Undeniably, it is a play for broader mainstream success for the model, and you’ll virtually hear writers tapping out sequels and spin-offs as you watch. However I am additionally somebody who’s had a whole lot of enjoyable with D&D over a few years, and the a part of my coronary heart that also holds a whole lot of affection for its world of mimics, fireballs and rust monsters could not assist however be warmed by a movie clearly made with buckets of real love and understanding of the sport.
As soon as its core occasion of adventurers has come collectively—together with a cocky bard (Chris Pine), a brutal barbarian (Michelle Rodriguez), a sorcerer with vanity points (Justice Smith) and an eco-warrior druid (Sophia Lillis)—the movie rapidly takes on the tempo and elegance of an awesome tabletop marketing campaign. Any common DM or participant will discover themselves recognising moments and tropes from their very own experiences—just like the occasion determining a weird, unintended use for his or her new magical merchandise, or an overpowered NPC stepping in to information them to a significant macguffin. One sequence sees the characters use a magic merchandise that lets them revive a corpse for precisely 5 questions earlier than it dies as soon as once more, and the ensuing bumbling investigation throughout a whole graveyard felt straight from my very own desk.
There’s an actual funding, too, within the Forgotten Realms setting—the longstanding D&D universe that is house to the likes of Baldur’s Gate and the Sword Coast. A lot of the plot takes place within the metropolis of Neverwinter, and contains factions just like the Harpers and the Pink Wizards of Thay in a manner that feels pure for the story, but additionally surprisingly respectful of the sport’s lore. Alongside the best way, traditional D&D monsters and spells make their appearances, from mind devourers to prestidigitation. However, vitally, the movie by no means will get slowed down in exposition—it largely trusts the viewers sufficient to only set up the foundations visually or by means of the motion, making certain it ought to play as nicely to audiences unfamiliar with the Monster Handbook as hardcore followers.
(opens in new tab)
It is from a complicated movie—it is mild and poppy, with way more spectacle than depth. You will see its main twists coming a mile away, and it struggles to provide its characters sufficient weight for its emotional beats to land successfully. However the Rule of Cool applies all through, with a inventive eye for motion that ensures that the spectacle is steadily riveting. Some well-used sensible results and sharp struggle choreography elevate even its easiest scenes—there are two sequences which are principally simply “Right here, watch the barbarian get offended and hit a load of individuals for a bit” and truthfully I might have been glad watching 10.
And as is perhaps anticipated coming from the administrators of missed comedy gem Sport Night time, it is actually humorous too. Although there are many Marvel-esque sarcastic one-liners, what works is that every character has their very own comedic voice—they do not simply stand round quipping Whedon-isms at one another as in so many blockbusters today. Even when not one of the characters are massively memorable, they’re a minimum of all distinct and likeable—and that is loads sufficient to get a movie this mild and agile over the end line with a cheeky grin on its face.
Contemplate the stain of the 2000 movie cleaned—Honor Amongst Thieves is nice enjoyable and about as trustworthy an adaptation of Dungeons & Dragons as any fan might hope to see on display screen. It is simple to consider this might actually be the launchpad into mainstream leisure that WOTC clearly hopes it will likely be. On the very least, there will be lots of people leaving the theatre keen to begin their subsequent—or first—marketing campaign.