You’ll be able to simply ignore any nintendo references and concentrate on the first features: the rumble, analog triggers, mechanical buttons, rgb-lights, swappable ABXY buttons, included swappable thumbsticks that are available 3 sizes.
TLDR: Out of all of the Nintendo Change controllers I at present personal it is most much like the Nintendo Change Professional Controller. The glossier end of the Professional Controller is smoother and appears extra enticing. It is price noting that in an actual world use the Mobapad M9-HD sits higher within the arms as a consequence of matte end & textured grips. When you worth ergonomics and just like the the Professional Controller (particularly the HD-rumble), it is possible that you’ll benefit from the the M9-HD. For the $75 retail value ($6 greater than Professional Controller) you’re going to get a significantly higher HD-rumble than the Professional Controller has (this shocked me essentially the most), analog triggers with two positions, mechanical buttons, mappable backpaddles, thumbsticks in numerous sizes and a number of further options.
Disclaimer: I began enjoying videogames within the early 90s (a NES clone was my first console, adopted by Gameboy, PC and many others). Outdoors of Reddit I’ve labored within the gaming tech discipline & tech journalism for about 20 years (Europe/Estonia). After offering the makers of Mobapad (Guangzhou Xinxiang Tradition Co. Ltd.) with my credentials (& examples of previous work), I requested if I may take a look at one in all their controllers with the aim of writing a assessment meant for the r/Change/ & r/NintendoSwitch/ subreddits. They despatched me the Mobapad M8 and Mobapad M9-HD. The assessment is be based mostly solely on my experiences. I get to maintain the controllers and will not be receiving further compensation in every other type (no fee charges, online marketing or ad-revenue and many others). I haven’t got a social media presence (or followers) elsewhere. As my Nintendo Change controller assortment grows, I’d write extra critiques for our Change-related subreddits.
Cheers 🙂
The Mobapad M9-HD Controller (with the tallest thumbsticks)
What this assessment is and isn’t.
There are numerous methods of protecting a tech product: from a extremely technical evaluation aimed on the tech-savvy crowd to an emotional hype-piece. The Mobapad M9-HD shall be reviewed as a controller on the Nintendo Change platform and in comparison with different Change controllers that I personal. A sensible quantity of actual life examples with a choose quantity of technical particulars shall be included (with temporary explanations which might be comprehensible to individuals who could be new to gaming). This assessment is not going to cowl each element concerning the M9-HD (equivalent to the entire options, how one can change numerous settings, how the controller works on different platforms and many others).
The package deal.
Out of all of the Nintendo Change Controllers I personal, the field of this controller is the perfect trying. The paintings is beautiful (IT’S A TIGER ON THE BOX – I believe), the field itself is sturdy. Whilst you cannot use the field to extend your goal in a videogame, you may put it on a shelf if you’re a collector or somebody who likes bins.
What’s within the field?
The controller itself, a USB-dongle receiver, a top quality braided USB-cable, a guide (in English), 4 units of thumbsticks and a couple of units of replaceable buttons (Change/PC structure).
On the left: Hori Cut up Pad Professional. On the suitable: the field of Mobapad M9-HD
Lets speak concerning the further buttons & potential for modding.
Having two units of buttons is a welcome further if you happen to play on a number of platforms. The guide mentions you can change the buttons, nevertheless it does not clarify how one can change them. It additionally doesn’t say you can/need to take away the faceplate. Seems that it’s a must to pry open the faceplate of the controller. Whereas I eliminated the largest portion of the faceplate, it actually felt that I’d break one thing whereas doing it. The faceplate is in three components & is linked to the controller with plastic connectors. I doubt that anybody who performs on a number of platforms (utilizing the identical controller) shall be motivated sufficient to swap the buttons from the Change to PC structure and again regularly.
Notice: The plastic connectors will in all probability get barely much less stiff with just a few removals of the faceplate, so it can turn out to be simpler to alter it. Utilizing magnetic connectors for the faceplate would in all probability have been a better option (like on the Mobapad M8 controller). It is also price noting that for these of us who like modding their controller, the flexibility to take away the faceplate is a pleasant further to have. Because it makes the customization course of simpler if you wish to paint the faceplate for instance.
RGB-lights!
The controller has some neat RGB-lights. They’re seen in 3 areas & in 8 completely different colours. The lights have 3 completely different modes (on, off, respiratory). Whereas altering the modes and colours of RGB-lights in a really speedy trend, I used to be capable of trigger an error. The lights did not change colour regardless that I pressed the button mixture to alter them. After ready for about 5-10 seconds the colours began to alter accurately once more. I used to be not capable of reproduce this bug later.
Do you want RGB-lights? Probably not. However they appear fairly and when Christmas comes round you may activate pink or yellow lights and be in a festive temper.
Mechanical A/B/X/Y buttons.
Merely put the A/B/X/Y buttons are mechanical, they’re clicky and a pleasure to make use of. Compared to common buttons (such those used within the Nintendo Change Professional Controller, Hori Cut up Pad Professional & Nintendo Change Joycons) the mechanical buttons within the Mobapad M9-HD are extra resnposive, could be pressed with much less pressure and make a small audible click on while you press them. As of late there are various keyboards that additionally include mechanical switches. If you have not had an opportunity to make use of a mechanical controller, you might need used a mechanical keyboard (or a mouse) which might produce an identical click on and feeling when pressed.
Notice: In a means I really feel that not together with the RGB-lights within the A/B/X/Y buttons is a missed alternative.
Closeup of the D-pad, RGB-lights, textured grip and buttons on the Mobapad M9-HD
What concerning the D-pad?
It is a good D-pad. The Mobapad M9-HD D-pad has a barely lowered/concave space across the D-pad equally to the Nintendo 64 controller’s D-pad. Urgent the D-pad on M9-HD takes barely much less pressure than it does on the Professional Controller’s D-pad. On the Change I would say that to this present day my favourite D-pad is on the 8Bitdo SN30pro (which is on the stiffer facet when it comes to the way it handles & the dimensions is ideal). The Nintendo Change Professional Controller’s D-pad is someplace between the M9-HD & SN30pro. I normally play handheld, however once I play with a controller, I do not normally select controllers based mostly on a style. So total, I am going to in all probability keep on with Mobapad M9-HD for many genres. On the uncommon events once I really feel nostalgic, I would in all probability go for the 8Bitdo SN30pro as a result of it jogs my memory of my childhood & first consoles.
Notice:: Because the A/B/X/Y and thumbsticks are swappable, I believe that it could be an attention-grabbing characteristic to have a swappable D-pad as nicely. One of many apparent inspiration factors for M9-HD has been the Xbox One Elite controller which has a swappable D-pad.
How are the thumbsticks?
Whereas there are 4 units of thumbsticks included, the thumbsticks are available 3 completely different heights. All of those are concave thumbsticks. The shortest thumbsticks are about 19mm extensive and much like the Hori Cut up Pad Professional. The medium & excessive thumbsticks are 18mm extensive (much like the Nintendo Change Professional Controller). The unique Nintendo Change joycons are about 15mm extensive. Altering the thumbsticks takes just a few seconds: you pull the thumbstick straight up and swap it to whichever of the included thumbsticks you fancy. On the technical facet it is price mentioning that these are ALPS thumbsticks.
What’s the good thing about altering thumbsticks?
It is a neat further that might make the controller extra snug to carry, eespecially when you’ve got medium/massive arms or play longer gaming classes. In sure genres (like FPS) increased thumbsticks could make it simpler to carry out extra exact actions. Often controllers don’t include completely different sized thumbsticks, however you should purchase thumbstick extenders that are bought by numerous manufacturers with the beginning value at round $12.
Ergonomics & how the controller feels to carry.
Out of the Nintendo Change controllers that I personal, the closest comparability could be to the Nintendo Change Professional Controller. It is price noting that the Professional Controller is barely shiny and feels easy within the hand. This makes the construct of Professional Controller really feel a tiny bit higher. The Mobapad M9-HD Controller is made out of matte plastic and has textured grips. The feel is slight but aggressive sufficient to make the controller really feel very safe. The situation of backpaddles feels ergonomic. Urgent the backpaddles feels good and you’ll map them to numerous buttons.
The M9-HD is at present essentially the most ergonomic Nintendo Change controller that I’ve used. The general consolation comes from the strong construct, completely different sized thumbsticks, superior triggers, mappable backpaddles and the burden plus the marginally textured grip.
The included swappable thumbsticks & further A/B/X/Y buttons of the Mobapad M9-HD
Gyro.
Gyro is current and by default fairly delicate. Normally gyro is not my most well-liked means of enjoying videogames, so take my “fairly delicate” impressions with a grain of salt, as I’ve additionally used gyro on the Nintendo Change Professional Controller and in addition discovered it a bit too delicate for my liking as nicely.
Triggers, analog triggers!
One of many main options that makes the Mobapad M9-HD stand out is the truth that the triggers are analog. In sensible phrases it means you can maintain the analog set off down partially, thus giving a restricted quantity of acceleration to your automobile in racing video games. This makes makes it rather more satisfying & simpler. On common controllers (such because the Nintendo Change Joycons or the Professional Controller) you may’t do this and need to consistently press and launch the set off to speed up, with out the choice to speed up shall we say 30% whereas simply barely urgent on the set off.
Sadly analog triggers operate as common triggers in most videogames on the Nintendo Change platform (except the developer of a sure videogame has included analog set off help to that particular recreation). So far as I do know, a really choose variety of videogames on the Nintendo Change embody analog set off help. GRID Autosport being one in all them, I’ve examined it with the Mobapad M9-HD & the analog triggers work. If any of you understand different Nintendo Change titles which have analog set off help, I would admire your remark. I need to strive them out and make sure if the triggers work in these video games.
One other neat characteristic of Mobapad M9-HD triggers is that they’ve two completely different positions you may select between. The shorter journey distance place has a pleasant clicky sound to it. As you may think about, the shorter distance makes it potential to press the triggers very quickly. The Nintendo Change Professional Controller set off feels barely mushy compared. I like utilizing each controllers, however the M9-HD feels higher. The longer journey distance place of the set off can also be good. By way of gameplay, it feels extra relaxed. In my gaming expertise the shorter distance is healthier for one thing like shooters or combating video games however longer is healthier for racing. Nevertheless it’s Nintendo Change in any case, so selecting which one is for you is a matter of desire. The nice factor is that on the M9-HD you could have a alternative in relation to set off journey distance. So far as I do know 8Bitdo additionally has a controller that has analog triggers with some adjustability, however I am unable to touch upon these as I do not personal that particular controller.
Notice: It is neat that extra firms equivalent to 8BitDo and Mobapad have began to supply controllers that assist you to configure how the triggers work. Hopefully we’ll see firms produce extra joycons in addition to controllers which have extra options sooner or later. I am certain Nintendo itself may pull it off simply, however I doubt they’ve any plans to do one thing like that within the close to future.
The HD-vibration motor.
Oh boy! That is in all probability the largest draw of utilizing this controller. I nonetheless keep in mind the primary time I felt the vibration motor of Mobapad M9-HD in my arms and I wasn’t anticipating it. My beforehand favourite vibration motor of the Change platform was within the Nintendo Change Professional Controller. I used to be certain that I’ll by no means ever see one other firm produce one thing of comparable high quality for the Change console.
Mobapad M9-HD did it and actually, the HD-vibration motor on Mobapad M9-HD is healthier than the Professional Controller’s vibration characteristic. It is onerous to clarify, however I am going to give it a shot. The rumble on Nintendo Change Professional Controller feels nice and does not rattle, so it is quiet in a means, however feels superb within the controller when enjoying and has some depth to the vibration. Mobapad M9-HD is a special beast. It has extra weight & energy to it along with the opposite options the Professional Controller’s vibration motor has. You’ll be able to immediately really feel that it is extra highly effective than the Professional Controllers HD-vibration. You’ll be able to really feel the bass of rumble in your arms when enjoying. And make no mistake, the elevated energy of Mobapad M9-HD vibration does not really feel creaky like a few of the decrease priced controllers could be. It feels highly effective, nicely balanced, does not make an excessive amount of sound and if I may, I would purchase joycons with the identical HD-vibration motor.
Notice: As the standard of the HD-vibration on Mobapad M9-HD shocked me significantly, I reached out to Mobapad and requested why the vibration feels completely different than in different Nintendo Change controllers. I obtained the next reply: “Our controller options linear motors, that are the most expensive half and what units it other than different controllers.” In a means this explains why the vibration is completely different from different third social gathering controllers, however why it feels so a lot better than the official Professional Controller’s vibration nonetheless puzzles me (perhaps a commerce secret?). Perhaps the motor is greater or has a greater place or one thing alongside these traces, who is aware of.
What else is there?
There are a number of options that I will not even try to cowl (the assessment is already an extended learn). The controller at present is available in black, white and purple. For the aim of the assessment I requested for the purple mannequin because it seems essentially the most cheerful. There’s additionally the NFC operate (I used to be not capable of take a look at this as I do not personal any Amiibos).
Ultimate ideas.
The Mobapad M9-HD is a nicely executed instance of a premium controller that appears to be primarily focused on the skilled gamer demographic. It is priced at $75 and is likely one of the highest priced Nintendo Change controllers on the market. By way of options it clearly competes with the Nintendo Change Professional Controller ($69.99-109.99$ relying on the colour scheme) & 8Bitdo Final Controller ($69.99). The value is price it for many who profit from the additional options (greatest HD-rumble, ergonomics, mechanical buttons, further thumbsticks and many others).
To me personally the pricing appears becoming to the options that the controller brings, nevertheless there are just a few extra features to think about.
Will a skilled gamer profit from the options that include the price? Sure, we’ll.
Will a more recent or informal gamer profit from the options? Sure, a few of them (just like the analog triggers, superior rumble and ergonomics that include swappable thumbsticks). Nonetheless I believe that since Mobapad as a model is not very well-known within the EU & US area, some could be hesitant to pay the total retail value.
Mobapad M9-HD simply out of the field, subsequent to Mobapad M8, Hori Cut up Pad Professional, 8Bitdo SN30pro (and the suitable deal with of Nintendo Change Professional Controller Splatoon Version.
And here’s a comparability desk.
I did my greatest to price numerous options of the Change controllers that I personal (with a view to give a form of an summary). Remember the fact that such comparisons are subjective and scores may differ from individual to individual (for instance somebody with very small arms may discover the Nintendo Change Joycons with the grip to be the perfect controller ever as a consequence of their dimension).
Score is on a scale of 1 to five (1 being the worst, 5 being the perfect).
The value is for the common mannequin of any controller and relies on the official pricing I discovered/obtained. This doesn’t embody gross sales or restricted version colour schemes that will price extra.
Mannequin | Nintendo Joycons + grip | Mobapad M9-HD | Nintendo Professional Controller | 8Bitdo SN30pro |
---|---|---|---|---|
D-Pad | 3 | 4.5 | 4 | 5 |
Thumbsticks | 3 | 5 | 4.5 | 4 |
Triggers | 3 | 5 | 3.5 | 3.5 |
Buttons | 3 | 5 | 3.5 | 4 |
Construct | 5 | 4.5 | 5 | 4.5 |
Ergonomics | 3.5 | 5 | 5 | 3 |
Options | 3.5 | 5 | 3.5 | 3 |
Included equipment | 3 | 5 | 3 | 3 |
Crossplatform help | 2 | 5 | 2 | 4.5 |
Vibration | 4 | 5 | 4 | 3 |
Value (not rated) | $79 | $75 | $69 | $45 |
Weight (not rated) | 197g | 254g | 249g | 112g |
What might be improved upon:
-
Whereas the bundled objects (such because the completely different thumbsticks and many others) are price the additional price to those that use them, it is possible that a few of the potential prospects won’t pay a lot consideration to the included extras and/or simply do not profit from them (since they do not customise their controller in any means and are proud of no matter configuration is shortly accessible out of the field).
-
A barely cheaper model of the Mobapad M9-HD that comes with much less extras (no replacable buttons or thumbsticks for instance) could be one thing that is price trying into. Such a transfer could make it simpler to decrease the worth barely. An excellent cheaper mannequin might be nearer to the Nintendo Change Professional Controller (so one thing like the present M9-HD however with out the choice to alter thumbsticks or buttons or faceplates).
-
Elevated availability within the western market could be useful (equivalent to a US & EU official shops or resellers).
-
My copy of the Mobapad M9-HD had a small barely sharp nook in one of many joints the place the underside & prime a part of the controllers case meet). When you maintain the controller whereas gaming, it is unlikely that you’d discover it. Whereas it is a minor challenge that may be simply mounted with gently sanding the sting with small piece of sandpaper or one thing abrasive, it is nonetheless one thing that might be mounted within the high quality management or manufacturing course of.
-
Extra colour schemes and designs for the controller may attraction to players. For instance the coloured (Splatoon version and many others) Nintendo Change Professional Controllers are highly regarded. Some firms have additionally produced controllers with a clear casing which can also be one thing that is price trying into. An upgraded model with RGB-lit A/B/X/Y buttons would even be neat.
-
An up to date guide that does a greater job at explaining all of the features (equivalent to how one can substitute the A/B/X/Y buttons) could be a welcome change.
-
The present package deal may be very nicely produced and has an total impact on the price of the merchandise. A barely smaller package deal may cut back the manufacturing price.
-
A semi-glossy model of the controller that makes use of related plastic to the Nintendo Change Professional Controller is one thing that might in all probability be nicely obtained by some players.
Here is a hyperlink to the entire photographs that I included on this submit.
Images gear used when taking these photographs: Fujifilm X-T4 mirrorless digicam, Fujinon XF 50-140mm f/2.8 R LM OIS WR lens, Fujifilm MCEX-11 macro extension tube.
Closing notes:
I hope you just like the assessment 🙂
My private because of Mr. Zhang & Amy from Guangzhou Xinxiang Tradition Co. Ltd.
Edit: I forgot to incorporate this half. In case you have some questions concerning the controller, be at liberty to ask. I’ll fortunately reply all of the questions I really feel competent sufficient to reply and the remainder I am going to accumulate and attain out to the individuals who made this. So we’ll get solutions from the corporate who constructed it.