Are you ever enjoying a Pokémon sport like Scarlet and Violet, fortunately operating across the open world catching critters and having ol’ time, if you immediately keep in mind Sport Freak stranded the protagonists of Pokémon Diamond and Pearl within the historical previous with no technique of returning to their family and friends within the modern-day?
Now that we’re a yr faraway from Pokémon Legends: Arceus, that’s all I can take into consideration after I keep in mind that sport. We’re so busy serious about Scarlet and Violet’s DLC that we forgot Pokémon Legends: Arceus by no means received new story content material after launch. With out it, the sport leaves a dangling plot thread too heartbreaking to bear.
Pokémon Legends: Arceus is the collection’ greatest narrative second
When you can’t deny the haunting ramifications of Pokémon Legends: Arceus’ conclusion, it’s value giving the Pokémon Isekai story its flowers for being one of the crucial compelling narratives within the collection’ 27-year historical past. The Change sport stars a teenage protagonist who seems suspiciously like Lucas and Daybreak, the primary characters of Pokémon Diamond and Pearl. Arceus, the god of the Pokémon universe, transports them to a time when Diamond and Pearl’s Sinnoh area had simply been found by settlers from different lands. At this level, it was referred to as Hisui, and Sinnoh refers solely to an unknown, almighty god whose origins are some extent of non secular dispute between the area’s indigenous Diamond and Pearl clans.
Welcome to Exp. Share, Kotaku’s weekly Pokémon column through which we dive deep to discover notable characters, city legends, communities, and simply plain bizarre quirks from all through the Pokémon franchise.
Our hero is dragged into many defining moments in Sinnoh’s historical past, from serving to to ease tensions between the rival clans to closing a space-time distortion rift that agitates highly effective Pokémon often called Nobles who reside over every of Hisui’s maps. Whereas it nonetheless has a whole lot of the trimmings of a typical Pokémon sport like turn-based battles and filling up a Pokédex with each identified Pokémon within the area, Legends: Arceus shakes up the formulation narratively by eradicating the collection’ typical aggressive sports activities framing. Catching and battling Pokémon aren’t ingrained in Hisui’s tradition but, so that you’re seeing long-established norms of the franchise at their origin level.
A lot of the sport is spent coping with on-the-ground points just like the non secular battle and Nobles, however as Legends: Arceus reaches its conclusion, it turns into clear the participant has been pulled into the previous for one thing a lot higher. The rift within the sky expands over the Temple of Sinnoh, which resides on the prime of Mt. Coronet, the middle level within the area. Right here, the participant faces both Dialga or Palkia, the gods of time and area within the Pokémon universe, relying on whether or not they aspect with the Diamond or Pearl clan earlier within the sport. The primary has appeared right here to convey a warning and to staff up with you to take down the opposite, who has grow to be enraged by the identical drive because the Nobles. The following battle destroys the Temple of Sinnoh, and all that’s left are the ruins Pokémon followers l know because the Spear Pillar in Diamond and Pearl.
Initially, it appears that is why the primary character was despatched by time to the Hisui area: to reserve it and permit it to develop and prosper into the Sinnoh everyone knows and love. The ultimate combat is stellar—as a Palkia diehard, I’ll always remember dealing with Dialga alongside him. It’s a shocking use of Sinnoh’s lore that lastly feels prefer it matches as much as the area’s place as an origin level for the universe. However the story isn’t completed till the post-credit segments.
The reality comes out, however no decision follows
After Dialga and Palkia are handled, there’s nonetheless the query of how the rift and the magical drive triggered the Nobles and one of many god Pokémon to grow to be so enraged within the first place. Our hero is requested by Volo, an enigmatic service provider, ally, and ancestor of future Sinnoh champion Cynthia, to assist seek for the fundamental plates which can be utilized by Arceus in battle to alter its elemental affinity, then to satisfy him at Spear Pillar. As soon as there, he reveals he’s been utilizing you to assemble these for his personal plans. It seems, Volo is the one behind all the things that’s occurred right here.
Volo is actually a spiritual zealot who has grow to be obsessive about Arceus. He believes that through the use of the plates, he can tame and management the god of the Pokémon universe to recreate the world in his picture. In a single fell swoop, Pokémon Legends: Arceus unmasks the true nature of its battle, and why the participant was despatched again in time to cease it. It is a battle between the Pokémon equivalents of God and Devil placing their two pawns on the board and dealing with each other as champions for his or her will.
The reveal that Cynthia’s ancestor, who you’d assume is an unwavering ally, just isn’t solely the villain behind all the things however is probably essentially the most harmful antagonist the collection has ever identified, stands out as among the best late-game reveals of the collection. All the things about this second, from the reveal, to the music, to the battle, elevates it to an all-time nice second in Pokémon historical past—till you end it and notice an actual conclusion isn’t coming.
After you beat Volo, you face Arceus. The god who introduced you again in time to face his nemesis challenges you to a check of your individual talent. However then…nothing occurs. Arceus by no means sends you again residence, it merely allows you to maintain trucking by the Hisui area at your leisure. On the time, I figured this was as a result of Sport Freak had plans to wrap issues up in DLC, however we’re a yr out and a sport later, and that conclusion by no means got here.
I’m certain there are individuals who will level out that the Isekai style seldom sends folks again to the place they got here from. However after Pokémon Legends: Arceus spends a lot time with the participant reflecting on their residence within the current day and speaking to the folks of Hisui about Pokémon battles and the life they as soon as lived, I wished the sport to not less than have interaction with that chance in its story, fairly than merely dropping its narrative off the aspect of Mt. Coronet. What makes this all of the more durable to parse is that there are hints that the primary character of Pokémon Legends: Arceus is similar character we performed as in Diamond and Pearl.
Is Pokemon Legends: Arceus’ protagonist the identical as Diamond and Pearl?
Not solely does the primary character look equivalent to Lucas and Daybreak from the DS video games, they’re additionally older than the standard 10-year-old we’re used to enjoying in a Pokémon sport—as a substitute they’re a 15-year-old coach from one other land. The protagonist of Pokémon Legends: Arceus is probably going an older model of Diamond and Pearl’s primary character, dragged by time to settle a dispute between the gods of the Pokémon universe. It makes some sense that after saving the Sinnoh area in a single sport that Arceus would think about them a befitting champion up to now. But it surely does make the shortage of an actual conclusion more durable to swallow, as a result of it is a hero who we as soon as guided to a happier finish, now left in time journey limbo. And so they’re not the one particular person trapped the place they don’t belong.
Ingo, one of many wardens for the Pearl clan, who acts as Sneasler’s keeper, appeared in one other sport, too. He, alongside his brother Emmett, are a part of the Battle Subway in Unova in Pokémon Black and White. Now that he’s within the Hisui area, he’s steadily shedding his recollections of his earlier life, and it’s solely when the protagonist can corroborate his seemingly incoherent rambling that the residents of Hisui begin to assume there is perhaps a future the place people and Pokémon stay alongside one another, fairly than people having to fastidiously combat their method by Hisui’s untamed environments. He additionally recollects his time spent combating trainers alongside his brother in Unova, however as a result of Arceus doesn’t ship him residence, these recollections are all he has of this previous life.
Now that it’s fairly clear Sport Freak has no intention of revisiting Pokémon Legends: Arceus any time quickly, we will assess how we really feel about its story with out the promise of recent content material. If, because the textual content suggests, it is a story of Lucas or Daybreak being despatched again in time to cease the Pokémon satan from annihilating the world we all know, its ending (or lack thereof) leaves it on a decidedly haunting be aware. Ingo and the protagonist are each caught in an unfamiliar time, shedding the chums, household, and Pokémon they left behind within the modern-day, For a sport that has one in all Pokémon’s greatest tales, it seems like an oversight to drop the thread of returning the participant again residence in favor of preserving the gameplay loop going. However Sport Freak by no means resolving this hanging plot thread with post-launch content material leaves you to marvel if it was an intentional alternative.
Is Legends: Arceus a greater story if it doesn’t resolve all the things and leaves us with these pangs of melancholy as we consider Lucas and Daybreak trapped within the distant previous? Is it in step with the sport’s decidedly darker tone and Pokémon’s pivot to extra mature storytelling in recent times to not give gamers the satisfying conclusion of seeing these characters again of their childhood bed room left within the sport’s recordsdata? Does it present progress that the collection is keen to take a seat with the uncomfortable truths of its world and lore fairly than ensuring all of it settles into its typical establishment ensuring Lucas and Daybreak are again residence in time to do Pokémon battles in entrance of crowds of adoring followers? Yeah, possibly.
Pokémon Legends: Arceus is the best-realized makes use of of the collection’ world, and maybe having a bittersweet ending is according to all the things that got here earlier than. It does make the sport one of the crucial attention-grabbing to consider, but it surely doesn’t imply it stings any much less.