On September 11, many of the over 4,000 staff at Ubisoft Montreal returned to workplace in Montreal’s Mile Finish for the primary time in three years. However hardly anybody appears completely happy about it, and lots of are livid at what they’re calling damaged guarantees from Ubisoft management.
Since Ubisoft Montreal introduced that staff could be returning to the workplace starting September 11, the studio’s intranet has been lighting up with posts starting from gentle concern to outright anger. IGN has considered a lot of feedback on the state of affairs throughout a number of Ubisoft inside postings, together with over 270 feedback on the announcement publish alone – nearly all of which have been destructive.
Most of the feedback record quite a few points staff have traditionally had working from the workplace earlier than as causes to not return: noisy calls in an open workplace, elevated bills, and a scarcity of enough tools or lodging. However the anger additionally runs deeper than the inherent issues with returning to the workplace. Amid a wider firm tradition of layoffs, recreation cancellations, and abuse allegations, this mandated workplace return appears to be the ultimate straw for a lot of staff who really feel that Ubisoft administration’s indifference to its staff has gone on lengthy sufficient.
Damaged Guarantees
Ubisoft’s overarching return to workplace plan throughout all its studios was first kicked off in the summertime of 2021, roughly coinciding with widespread availability of the primary vaccines towards the COVID-19 pandemic. However in Montreal, the place Far Cry 6, Curler Champions, For Honor, and a number of Murderer’s Creed video games have been made, staff inform IGN that the corporate’s publicly touted plan merely…by no means occurred.
As an alternative, they are saying they have been reassured repeatedly over two years that they might stay 100% distant long-term, with many staff making main life choices and even accepting job affords assuming they might earn a living from home for the foreseeable future. IGN has considered a lot of paperwork circulated on the corporate intranet over the previous few years that appear to again up this perception. In a single instance, Ubisoft guarantees a “hybrid, versatile working setting” the place “100% distant work might be attainable relying on varied standards, reminiscent of productiveness and influence on the workforce, in addition to the character of the work being achieved.”
However now that’s altering. Starting September 11, 2023, Montreal staff are anticipated to work a minimal of two days every week out of the workplace. The requirement is necessary for all staff, with exemptions solely made for workers with express wants “as soon as all different options have been explored.”
The announcement instantly sparked anger throughout the studio, with posts on the corporate’s intranet itemizing quite a few points staff have traditionally had working from the workplace earlier than as causes to not return: noisy calls in an open workplace, transit prices, and a scarcity of enough tools or lodging for particular accessibility wants and dealing types. A handful of staff introduced up the standard of the Montreal workplace particularly, mentioning previous points reminiscent of leaks, rats, bugs, and dearth of typical workplace perks reminiscent of free espresso. A number of raised well being issues, citing ongoing fears concerning the unfold of COVID-19. And lots of builders accused Ubisoft of breaking its guarantees round 100% work-from-home, with a number of staff saying they’d both accepted a job at Ubisoft or made a significant life change (reminiscent of shopping for a home outdoors of Montreal) believing it was a everlasting coverage.
One key theme in lots of feedback is a broader lack of belief within the firm to offer good working circumstances and preserve its guarantees over time. It’s been three years for the reason that firm was rocked with allegations of a poisonous work setting, however some staff have publicly claimed these allegations have but to be sufficiently addressed. On high of that, the corporate has now achieved a number of rounds of layoffs simply this 12 months amid a lot wider monetary cuts, cancelled a lot of each introduced and unannounced video games, and seen a number of others launch and underperform. With that a lot chaos so readily obvious externally, it’s unsurprising {that a} Montreal return-to-office renege is serving as the ultimate straw for a lot of.
A number of staff have gone so far as to invest that the change was successfully a delicate layoff on the a part of Ubisoft in an effort to assuage mentioned latest monetary woes. By introducing an unpopular coverage, they prompt, Ubisoft might push staff to stop and scale back headcount with out having to pay severance or cope with different potential monetary drawbacks of a mass layoff.
A number of commenters identified that Ubisoft Montreal has lengthy had agreements with the Quebec and Montreal governments to convey jobs and foot visitors to Montreal, in return for vital tax credit which have pushed wider business development within the province. However this system has traditionally been a controversial one, and its deserves might be underneath scrutiny once more amid Montreal’s wider struggles to rejuvenate its downtown post-pandemic and a broader development in employee disinterest in return to workplace.
“The weblog publish cited issues like ‘Ubisoft tradition’ and ‘collaboration’ as the explanations we would have liked to return to the workplace, however by no means as soon as defined what issues a scarcity of these items had triggered, or what steps had been taken to alleviate them earlier than turning to RTO as the answer, or what sort of modifications administration expects to see on account of RTO and the way we’re to measure the success of this plan,” one worker instructed IGN. “The shortage of substance about why we’re doing this and the way can we all know if it is working has led lots of people to imagine the explanations we’re being given are lies and the administration are afraid to say the actual causes out loud.”’
An Imminent Exodus?
Whereas staff are being inspired to talk with particular person managers for lodging, Ubisoft’s inside documentation has implied that exemptions “will solely be thought of as soon as all different options have been explored.” In the meantime, a number of staff IGN spoke to have attested that Ubisoft’s system for locating these options isn’t working nicely so far. One mentioned that staff who’ve been utilizing standing desks or different particular tools from house are unable to get what they want in-office with out “a battle and 20 physician’s notes”.
What’s extra, the lodging system appears to be bottlenecking shortly attributable to a flood of requests, and never sufficient folks to meet them. One other particular person famous that Ubisoft leaders look like delegating duty managing worker frustration to center managers, who appear largely powerless to deal with the anger.
IGN reached out to Ubisoft for touch upon this story, and obtained the next assertion in response:
Like many firms in leisure and tech, we’re asking our colleagues to return again to the workplace for key moments recognized by every workforce. We’re satisfied that the synergy, in-person discussions, fast iterations, and a way of belonging that occurs extra in particular person will assist us be simpler and agile collectively, and obtain our enterprise targets.
First introduced early in June, the hybrid mode goes into place on Monday, September 11, and we’re accompanying our colleagues by these modifications, giving them extra flexibility over the subsequent eight weeks or extra to adapt. Open and ongoing conversations along with intensive particular person lodging and preparations are at the moment underway to ease this transition and the influence on everybody’s well-being, which stays our precedence to proceed to ship nice video games.
Whereas it stays to be seen how the unpopular return to Ubisoft Montreal’s workplace will influence the studio long-term, one attainable mannequin might be discovered over at Blizzard. Like Ubisoft, Blizzard has equally been embroiled in a sequence of very public upheavals over its work tradition, seen a wave of worker collective motion, and laid off tons of over the past few years. After which, like Ubisoft, Blizzard instituted its personal equally unpopular pressured return-to-office earlier this 12 months. So what occurred to Blizzard? Nicely, in line with Blizzard builders on social media, the RTO coverage resulted in a mass exodus of expertise so impactful that at one level that the corporate was creating “disaster maps” of what it might and couldn’t ship with the folks it had left.
Whether or not or not Ubisoft will comply with swimsuit stays to be seen, although a lot of worker feedback implied and even outright said that the coverage change had sparked them to search for work elsewhere. Latest historical past, too, signifies that staff are fed as much as the purpose of departure. [Update: Ubisoft reached out post-publication to note that Ubisoft rehired 600 former employees in fiscal 2021-22.] With Ubisoft as an organization greedy for a return to kind after a number of gross sales disappointments, delays, and cancellations, one wonders how for much longer it could afford to enrage and upset its largest and most prolific improvement studio.
Rebekah Valentine is a senior reporter for IGN. Bought a narrative tip? Ship it to rvalentine@ign.com.